For Progressives, Michelle Wu Points to a Way Forward

BOSTON — For progressives, Tuesday’s elections brought a litany of bad news and one conspicuous bright spot: Michelle Wu, the newly elected mayor of Boston, who took the stage in a scarlet dress, carrying her 4-year-old son on her hip.

Ms. Wu, 36, was in intense campaign mode this summer when Eric Adams won the Democratic primary in New York, convincing many pundits that the progressive movement was sputtering at the ballot box, dampened by the practical concerns of older, moderate voters.

Ms. Wu had time to pivot toward the center, but she did not: Right up until its last weeks, her campaign was built around an agenda that galvanized this city’s young left, like fare-free public transit, climate action and rent control.

And that did not seem to hurt her, even with centrist voters. In Tuesday’s election, Ms. Wu trounced a more moderate opponent, City Councilor Annissa Essaibi George, by a 28-point margin. Between the September preliminary election and Tuesday’s general election, she expanded far beyond the younger, more educated whites who are her base, winning by commanding margins among Black, Latino and Asian voters.

Still flushed from her victory, Ms. Wu affirmed her plan to make the city into a laboratory for progressive policy, the kind she studied under her mentor Senator Elizabeth Warren.

“Boston has come together to reshape what is possible,” she told supporters. “We are the city of the first public school in the country, the first public park, the first subway tunnel. We are the city of revolution, civil rights, marriage equality. We have always been that city that punches above our weight.”

Ms. Wu was supported by Senator Elizabeth Warren, a national progressive leader.Credit…Philip Keith for The New York Times

Ms. Wu’s campaign — and particularly her “years of infrastructure building and engagement” — should be a model for progressive candidates across the country, said Adam Green, co-founder of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, which endorsed her.

“She doesn’t just represent transformational ideas in a vacuum; she was someone who built credibility in the local community over the years,” he said. “We’ve lost races when the candidates swing out of nowhere, and the first time people are hearing of them is when they run for office.”

One explanation for her success is Ms. Wu herself, who is difficult to caricature as a radical.

Over her four terms as a city councilor, Bostonians have gotten to know Ms. Wu as soft-spoken and thoughtful, intensely focused on policy, meticulous about showing up at meetings and returning phone calls. That experience acted as a “buffer,” if any was needed, “for someone this progressive to be elected mayor,” said David Paleologos, director of the Suffolk University Political Research Center.

“That kind of quiet, methodical style is a new style for progressives,” he said. “It’s a different kind of style that she has invented.”

Lydia Chim, 26, a budget analyst who moved to Boston from California, said Ms. Wu struck her as experienced and practical, qualities she does not always find in progressives.

“It’s a refreshing thing to see a progressive candidate who really knows how to get things done,” she said.

Ms. Wu also cultivated relationships with the city’s conservative power centers, tapping into her Harvard pedigree and post-college experience as a management consultant and small-business owner. She comes across as “somebody who is very clearly into managing systems,” which has helped her build trust in those parts of the city, said Jonathan Cohn, the chair of a local Democratic committee and a progressive activist.

“Her career is where it is because she has done a good job of catering to business owners and progressives at the same time,” he said.

Ms. Wu has also benefited from some conditions outside her control.

The demographics of Boston are changing rapidly, with young professionals drawn to the city for jobs in technology, medicine and education. Boston has become “an intellectual elite city,” said Nan Whaley, the mayor of Dayton, Ohio, and the president of the U.S. Conference of Mayors. Its politics, she said, are changing accordingly.

“Boston might be a harbinger for the situation in our big cities,” she said. “They are expensive to live in. People are more educated. That might be a difference we will see.”

It helped that the popular incumbent, Mayor Martin J. Walsh, was tapped as the federal labor secretary in January, leaving the Boston race wide open. By then, Ms. Wu was four months into a campaign against Mr. Walsh, criticizing his administration for insufficient action to combat racial injustice and climate change.

In open races, it is not unusual for voters to opt for a candidate who has characteristics the previous mayor did not, said David Axelrod, a Democratic political consultant.

Takeaways From the 2021 Elections

Card 1 of 5

A G.O.P. pathway in Virginia. The win by Glenn Youngkin, who campaigned heavily in the governor’s race on education and who evaded the shadow of Donald Trump, could serve as a blueprint for Republicans in the midterms.

A rightward shift emerges. Mr. Youngkin outperformed Mr. Trump’s 2020 results across Virginia, while a surprisingly strong showing in the New Jersey governor’s race by the G.O.P. candidate is unsettling Democrats.

Democratic panic is rising. Less than a year after taking power in Washington, the party faces a grim immediate future as it struggles to energize voters and continues to lose messaging wars to Republicans.

A new direction in N.Y.C. Eric Adams will be the second Black mayor in the city’s history. The win for the former police captain sets in motion a more center-left Democratic leadership.

Mixed results for Democrats in cities. Voters in Minneapolis rejected an amendment to replace the Police Department while progressives scored a victory in Boston’s mayoral race.

“They choose the remedy” to the previous mayor, “someone who has what they lacked, rather than a replica of who they are,” he said.

Another factor was something in full view at Ms. Wu’s victory party on Tuesday night: a young, enthusiastic, racially diverse ground operation.

Young people in Massachusetts have been drawn powerfully into organizing, cutting their teeth on the presidential campaigns of Ms. Warren and Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont and emerging as a formidable political force in the re-election of Senator Ed Markey.

Ms. Wu hosted events for youth organizers more than a year ago, shortly after declaring her candidacy. Alejandra Tejeda, 24, of the Hyde Park neighborhood, attended one, and was so impressed that she departed as a full-fledged passenger on “the Wu train,” as it is known.

Her activism consisted mainly of arguing Ms. Wu’s case with old friends and classmates over Facebook, something she likened to “virtual door-knocking.” But for many others, “everything about their life became Michelle Wu.”

Ms. Tejeda and her best friend, Malaysia Fuller-Staten, exulted on Tuesday. They attended Ms. Wu’s victory party in matching Wu T-shirts, danced a little, and headed home at 11:30, satisfied by what they had achieved. “Young people in Boston definitely played a large role in helping elect Michelle Wu,” she said.

Malaysia Fuller-Staten, who supported Michelle Wu’s campaign, is now prodding the mayor-elect to act on the proposals she campaigned on.Credit…M. Scott Brauer for The New York Times

And as the glow of victory recedes, Ms. Wu will face pressure from the same activists, who are eager to see action on the proposals she ran on: cuts to the police budget, the expansion of fare-free transit, and progress toward restoring rent control.

For Ms. Fuller-Staten, that started on Wednesday morning at 8, when she began publicly prodding the mayor-elect to find housing for several hundred people who were recently evicted from a sidewalk tent city.

“Alright,” she wrote on Twitter, “the sun has risen on a new day and it’s time to figure out what Mayor-elect Michelle Wu is going to about the housing issues” in that area.

And that should be expected, Ms. Fuller-Staten said.

“It’s a new game in politics these days, especially in a place like Massachusetts,” she said. “If we’re going to put any of our time behind you, whether it’s ground work or even just tweeting, we expect that you give us what we were looking for when we supported you.”

“It’s not like we supported you and now it’s done,” she said.

Back to top button